Thoughts about roof-plugin

[youseeus]

Hi, I'm working with sh3d since more than 5 years. [:x]
But I'm still unhappy with the way roofs are created. [>:)]

I'm a developer so I'm thinking about, how to improve it. But I don't know if I'll have the time to get it done all myself*) [:p].

• roofs align with the shape of the outer walls
• roofs have gabels and eaves (mostly aligned with the outer walls)
• there are different shapes in between: roof documentation for OSM

So how to Build a roof:
atm: place several models to come as close to the original as possible.
My idea:

• create a new level
• Place the gabel (vertices and edges)
• add properties like roof overhang, pitch and other (vertices and edges can have different properties each)
• place pitched windows (models)
• let the program calculate the roof
• the program will
  • create a model for rendering
  • align the inner walls so no wall is sticking through the roof

what do you think about the idea? Have i forgotten a big blocker? [:-/]

*)We are building a house rn, there isn't so much time left for programming

[hansmex]

Your description of an algorithm is just the start. The truth is quite a bit more complex. The OSM list describes many roof types, but hardly covers everything.

Take a look here : this kind of house with dormers, and many different roof sections is quite common in the US.

Trying to write a plug-in that could make such a roof wouldn't be easy.

H

[Puybaret]

Thanks for the roof document link, it gives a good idea of various roofs and their parameters. But to ensure you reach your goal, you should probably start with a few roof simple models.

I would suggest that you inspire yourself from ShapeGenerator plug-in source code (it's included in the plug-in), i.e. create roof shapes with Java 3D classes, then export those shapes at OBJ format with OBJWriter class, finally create a HomePieceOfFurniture instance and add it to the edited home.
If you need to keep some parameters for the computed roof to update it afterwards, feel free to set your own properties on the HomePieceOfFurniture instance.

As it's possible to rotate objects around an horizontal axis, you could also try to create a roof by assembling flat boxes and triangles, but I think this will be more complicated to program.

[youseeus]

yes i know its just the description of the general idea. And you can't cover every roof type. But your link would be covered by my idea. The most complex thing i see is to get the align of the subroof right. But i wouldn't go for absolute perfection in the first Version. There are still the current ways.

thanks for the ShapeGenerator-hint [:)]

[youseeus]

Hi, I have a first draft for the roof designer at the bottom of this post.
You draw the gabel and enter your properties in the dialog.

Currently i just use a polyline and store all informations in the properties.
The next step is to generate a roof object from that informations.

I'm not really happy with the polyline approach. But I have no better idea how to draw and store the gabel at this moment.
My goal is that you can see the gabel in the plan.

What do you think?

[okh]

Very interesting (even if I agree with the posts saying that it will be complicated in the real world)

Several years ago I briefly used some software or other (IMSI Floor plan, I think), with an automatic roof option. For a simple roof, on a simple plan, it worked beautifully. But was not much help when it came to a plan with more than two walls of equal height and two walls with a gable.

On the other hand, my guess is that a simple roof might still be useful. And to that effect, your approach with a clean interface looks very good.

So - yes - idea very interesting. Looking forward to trying anything you come up with.

ok

[youseeus]

do you mean something like this?:

[Puybaret]

It's great that you could start to program this plug-in.
The polyline is a nice way to get some coordinates by reusing existing features of Sweet Home 3D. I would suggest that you request to draw this line in a clone of the current home that will display only walls. You could display this clone in your dialog box with your own plan component / controller, using subclasses of PlanComponent and PlanController classes (VideoPanel class uses for example a subclass of [font=courier new]PlanComponent[/font]). If you're interested by this, just ask for more details.

[ndorigatti]

This thread is very interesting and I'm following this! I would like to have the time to help, but I neither have the time to update my home unfortunately.

I currently created custom components for my roof, and i do have a dormer that "cuts" half of the roof to create space for a big door window.
I would also point out that usually (at least here where i live) roofs extends over the walls and covers also the outside!

[okh]

do you mean something like this?

Not even that, where the other software failed was a little, rectangular cabin 22m² with a gabled roof. So far so good. However, my father had built a 9m² annexe on the long side with a roof angle different from the main construction. This I could never create with the automatic roof function in the other software.

Now even if I had to make the roof myself, the result was much better in SH3D.

My point being - that even a simple automated roof can be a great help. But I agree with hansmex and the others, that getting (even slightly) more complicated designs to work, may not be possible.

ok

P.S. Maybe hard to see, but to the left of the building the roof is slightly different. So with SH3D I could get the roof right.

(Sorry, this is an old image from an old thread .)